Thanks for the input Andrew and Rodney. A spring over would certainly be easier/cheaper for me. I've also worked on so many stock spring over axles over the years, Andrew, that I've been wondering why it couldn't work. Like you say, Rodney, it seems to have a lot to do with the spring rate, but as I have brand new (literally no miles driven on them) repo stock springs, they are far from worn out. I just don't know if the spring rate stock will be enough to prevent axle wrap issues. Though I also have several sets of old leaf springs from Willys just laying around too, so I could possibly play around with adding an extra leaf if stability, axle wrap is an issue with a spring over. I just don't want to cause the ride quality to suffer too greatly in the process of course.
Though I know another contributing factor with axle wrap is horsepower and torque output of the drivetrain too, as well as lower axle ratios. I'll be running a Chevy inline 6cyl that was mildly built, so not an overly high horsepower/torque engine overall (not V8 level power certainly), though easily more then the stock Willys 226 engine would have been. The axle ratio is also the stock 4.27:1, pretty low though, so neither of these factors will help issues when it comes to possible axle wrap. By the way, Andrew, I'm not worried about the steering as I'm going to do a power steering box conversion with crossover steering at the same time. So I won't be using the original short Willys' draglink (or really much else of the stock system).
The benefit to a spring over (in addition to ground/wheel clearance) is better articulation, or so I've read, though for a wagon that is going to see dirt roads and highway miles more then off-road and trail rides, this isn't my number one concern. I just don't want something that will handle horribly on pavement as a trade off for the extra lift/off-roading capability. If a spring under is more stable in this regard, and can be achieved without making ride quality substantially worst (stiffer spring rates), then it is the better option. However, if a spring over will still allow for stable handling (at least as stable as it is stock) on road and in traffic (changing lanes, making turns), then it would be a viable option too in my opinion. Anyone with a spring over (especially a stock Willys axle/spring set up) care to comment on that possibility?
Edit:
To your point, Andrew, though a bad example perhaps due to it being a heavy duty truck, with equally heavy duty (stiff) springs, my father's '51 Chevy cab over is a spring over both front (I-beam) and rear.
View attachment 86067