I found Formica to be ideal. Available in all sorts of colors and textures. Not affected by moisture like the original pasteboard. It is 1/16" thick. I used a RotoZip type tool -miniature router- to cut it. All the saws I tried chipped it.What options were available for kick panels on Jeepsters? I assume what's left on mine is not original, but I've seen all manner of different materials in photos, though mostly vinyl of one fashion or another.
View attachment 39707